County AD: Broadneck Coach Let Shaving Swimmer Compete

The team's coach couldn't be there for their weekend victory in the regional championship due to a one-meet ban.

Update (Feb. 24 at 10:25 a.m.)—This article reflects new information about who first reported the infraction to Winans.

 Bruins swimmer  had told the coach of the infraction, but was allowed to compete anyway, a school official told Patch on Thursday.

County Athletic Program Supervisor Greg LeGrand said the infraction was reported to Bruins coach Colleen Winans before the meet began, but she chose to let her swim.

Winans said she first heard about the incident from the coach of another team, who heard it from a student who saw the female swimmer shaving.

“The student should have been disqualified to begin with,” LeGrand said. “We expect our coaches to knowingly abide by the rules. We do not think it’s appropriate that the coach knew the rule, confirmed the rule, and then knowingly violated the rule.”

Shaving on-site before a swim meet is a violation of the National Federation of State High School Associations’ (NFHS) rulebook. The practice of shaving on-site before a meet is prohibited for health and safety reasons, according to the NFHS' website.

As a result, the swimmer’s points were redistributed and the Bruins placed third at their Feb. 10 meet. Their rivals, the  Falcons, took first place in the county championship.

Winans was banned for one meet for her involvement in the incident, preventing her from attending the team's regional championship victory Saturday. The team is now qualified for the state championship.

LeGrand said Winans informed the school's athletic director Ken Kazmarek of the incident on her own.

“She felt she had a bad lapse of judgment, and said she made an error and wanted to set the record straight,” LeGrand said. “We held no additional issue with the student because she was up front and honest about what happened.”

Patch is attempting to reach Winans for comment.

Broadneck swimmer Lauren Fogarty told The Capital after winning the 100-meter-breaststroke at regionals that she wanted to make Winans proud, despite the fact that she couldn’t be there. 

Katherine Woods, the mother of a Bruins swimmer, said despite the disqualification in the earlier meet, the girls should hold their heads high. 

"It is unfortunate that the rule infraction resulted in the girls losing the title. The girls team can take pride in the fact that they swam better than all the other teams at the county meet," Woods said. "They worked hard and have an excellent coach who runs a really good program."

The 2012 state championship is scheduled for Saturday at the University of Maryland in College Park.

Bill February 23, 2012 at 08:31 PM
Great follow up to yesterday's story, it should put to rest many of the comments and questions that have been posted. My one question is why did it take so long for the county to announce it and why did they do such a poor job with reporting the details in the press release? The delay and the absence of information only led to speculation and rumor.
anonymous February 25, 2012 at 04:50 AM
It's ridiculous that LeGrand and Kasmarak allowed this student to precipitate and wouldn't even attempt to make an appeal for Collin Harrell. The swimmer knew what she did was wrong and so did the coach. Yet, a kid that sticks up for his mother, they will not support. Unreal that they didn't contact the North County administration and didn't give this kid a chance. I guess if you get hurt in the begin of the season and are one of the best kids in the state you don't get that kind of support. Yet if you break the rules it's ok you can go compete next week. Good luck this weekend and next weekend girls. I'm not upset with you. I'm upset with the whole athletic adminstration.


More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something
See more »